How to Compare Two Marketing Proposals for Your Clinic (With a Scoring Template)

To compare two marketing proposals for your clinic, put them into the same shape before you look at price. List what each delivers every month, what it leaves out, who does the work, how results will be measured and what the total monthly cost is with ad spend included. Then score both against the same weighted criteria. Very different packages usually mean each agency has diagnosed a different problem, so start there.
This guide widens our SEO proposal checklist to full marketing proposals that mix SEO, paid ads, websites and social. It includes a like-for-like comparison table and a scoring template you can copy. If you have not yet met the agencies, start with our 20 questions to ask a healthcare marketing agency.
Why are marketing proposals so hard to compare?
Agencies package work differently on purpose. One proposes a new website and SEO; another proposes Google Ads and social with no website work. One quotes a fee that includes ad spend; another quotes management only. One lists hours, another lists outputs, a third lists neither. Comparing the headline figures tells you very little.
Healthcare adds layers a general proposal may skip: clinical review of content, advertising rules on claims and prescription-only medicines, consent for patient images, and tracking that respects health data. A cheaper proposal sometimes leaves those costs for you to carry.
Step 1: Check what problem each proposal is solving
Read the diagnosis before the price. A good proposal says what it found in your current marketing and why it recommends its plan. Write one sentence for each: "Agency A thinks our problem is X, so it proposes Y."
- Does it reflect your specialty, location and capacity, or could it be sent to any clinic?
- Does it refer to evidence, such as your Search Console data, ad account or website speed?
- Does it say which services it would promote first and why?
- If the two diagnoses disagree, which one matches what you see in your diary and enquiries?
If neither proposal includes a diagnosis, ask for one before going further. A free SEO audit or account review is a reasonable request.
Step 2: Rebuild both proposals in one table
Copy each proposal's contents into the same rows. Gaps show up quickly, and so do items that sound different but are the same work.
| Line | What to write down | Proposal A | Proposal B |
|---|---|---|---|
| Diagnosis | The problem the agency says it is solving | ||
| Monthly deliverables | Pages, campaigns, posts, links, fixes, with numbers | ||
| One-off work | Website, landing pages, set-up, tracking | ||
| Not included | Ad spend, photography, software, copywriting, clinical review | ||
| People | Named roles, main contact, holiday cover | ||
| Compliance | Who checks claims and how, against which rules | ||
| Measurement | Calls, forms, bookings, cost per new patient | ||
| Reporting | Frequency, format, meetings | ||
| Ownership | Website, domain, ad accounts, analytics, content | ||
| Terms | Minimum term, notice period, review points |
Step 3: Work out the real monthly cost
The figure that matters is the total cost of getting the planned results, not the fee on the front page.
- Management fees for each channel.
- Ad spend the plan needs to work, paid to Google or Meta. If a proposal bundles it into the fee, ask for the split.
- Set-up and one-off costs, spread over 12 months so they compare with monthly fees.
- Extras you would buy anyway: photography, landing pages, call tracking, booking software.
- Your own time: clinician review, approvals and enquiry handling.
Then ask what each total is expected to achieve and how soon. Our guides to healthcare SEO costs and PPC management costs give market context, and how much clinic marketing costs by specialty shows how the mix shifts between aesthetics, dental, fertility and weight loss.
Step 4: Score both proposals with a weighted template
Score each criterion from 1 to 5, multiply by its weight, divide by 5 and add up. The weights below total 100 and reflect what tends to decide results for private clinics. Adjust them to your priorities before you score, not after.
| Criterion | Weight | What a 5 looks like | What a 1 looks like |
|---|---|---|---|
| Diagnosis and fit | 20 | Specific to your clinic, backed by your data | Generic plan that could suit any business |
| Clarity of deliverables | 15 | Numbered monthly outputs and dates | "Ongoing optimisation" with no detail |
| Compliance and clinical review | 15 | Written review step against the CAP Code and your regulator | Not mentioned |
| Measurement to bookings | 15 | Tracks calls, forms and booked consultations | Stops at traffic and rankings |
| People and capacity | 10 | Named team and cover | Unclear who does the work |
| Total cost against scope | 10 | All costs visible, ad spend separate | Single figure with hidden extras |
| Ownership and terms | 10 | You own every account; short notice period | Agency owns accounts; long tie-in |
| Healthcare evidence | 5 | Dated, sourced case studies in similar work | Logos or claims with no detail |
An illustrative scoring, not a real comparison: Proposal A scores 4 on diagnosis (4 × 20 ÷ 5 = 16) and Proposal B scores 2 (8). Repeat for every line. A gap of a few points means the proposals are close and the conversation with each team should decide. A gap of 15 or more usually points to a clear choice.
For compliance, a good proposal will mention that objective claims need evidence and that prescription-only medicines cannot be advertised to the public, both in CAP Code section 12. If a proposal's sample ads name Botox or weight-loss injections, score compliance at 1. Our guide to advertising prescription-only medicines explains why. This is general guidance, not legal advice.
What are the red flags in a marketing proposal?
- Guaranteed rankings, leads or patient numbers. Nobody controls those.
- Ad spend hidden inside the fee, so you cannot see what goes to Google or Meta.
- The agency owns the ad account, website or domain. Google's own help pages recommend more than one administrator on an account so access is never lost.
- Pay per lead with no definition of a lead. See our guide to pay-per-patient deals.
- Long fixed terms with no review points.
- No step for checking clinical claims, or sample ads that would breach the rules.
- Reporting that stops at impressions and clicks, with no link to enquiries or bookings.
What should you send back before deciding?
- Ask each agency to fill in the comparison table above in its own words.
- Ask for the ad spend each plan assumes, and what happens if you spend less.
- Ask for a sample monthly report, anonymised.
- Ask who will do the work and meet them.
- Ask what the first 90 days include, week by week.
- Ask for the contract terms: notice period, ownership and exit.
Our 2026 checklist for choosing a healthcare marketing agency covers what good answers look like, and what a monthly retainer should include helps you test the deliverables.
What this means for your clinic
To compare marketing proposals fairly, compare the diagnosis first, rebuild both in one table, work out the real monthly cost and score them with weights you set in advance. The cheaper proposal is only cheaper if it delivers the same work to the same standard. For reference, our healthcare marketing pricing page sets out how we quote: SEO from £1,000 a month for solo and individual doctors, clinic quotes after a review, 30 days' notice and no long tie-ins.
Frequently asked questions
How do I compare two marketing proposals?
Rebuild both in one table: diagnosis, monthly deliverables, one-off work, exclusions, people, compliance, measurement, ownership and terms. Work out the total monthly cost including ad spend and set-up spread over a year.
Then score each against weighted criteria you agree before reading the prices, and discuss the gaps with each agency.
What should a healthcare marketing proposal include?
A diagnosis of your current marketing, numbered monthly deliverables, one-off work, what is excluded, who does the work, how claims are checked against the CAP Code and your regulator, how results are tracked to bookings, reporting, account ownership, and the term and notice period.
Ad spend should be shown separately from fees.
Should I choose the cheaper marketing proposal?
Only if it delivers the same work to the same standard. Cheaper proposals often leave out content writing, clinical review, tracking or landing pages, which you then pay for separately or go without. Compare the total cost of the planned results, not the headline fee, and check what each excludes.
How do I compare an SEO proposal with a Google Ads proposal?
They work on different timescales, so compare what each expects to deliver and when. Google Ads can bring enquiries within weeks while you pay for clicks; SEO builds over months into visibility you own.
Ask both agencies for expected enquiries over 12 months and the total cost, including ad spend, to reach them.
What contract terms should I look for in a marketing proposal?
A short notice period, review points, clear deliverables and ownership of the website, domain, ad accounts, analytics and content by your clinic. Avoid long fixed terms with no review and any clause that charges to release your own accounts. Ask for the terms in writing before you sign.
Can I ask an agency to change its proposal?
Yes. A good agency will adjust the scope, phasing or channels to fit your budget and capacity, and explain what changes as a result. Ask what it would drop first if the budget were lower, and why.
How an agency handles that conversation tells you a lot about working with it.
